Multi-Site Survey of Victims of Crime and Criminal Justice Professionals across Canada: Summary of Defence Counsel Respondents: Summary of Defence Counsel Respondents

TABLE 14: OBSTALCES OR PROBLEMS WITH VICTIM IMPACT STATEMENTS
BASE: RESPONDENTS WHO BELIEVE THERE ARE OBSTACLES OR PROBLEMS WITH VICTIM IMPACT STATEMENTS
Main Reasons Cited: Victim Services (n=105) Crown Attorneys (n=90) Defence Counsel (n=147) Police (n=128)
Inappropriate or irrelevant material -- 43% 31% --
Contain inflammatory or prejudicial claims -- -- 18% --
Inject emotion into the process -- -- 13% --
Difficulties preparing statement or insufficient assistance 32% -- -- --
Lack of awareness or information 17% -- -- 2%
Defence counsel objections or cross-examination 16% 18% -- 21%
Difficult to challenge -- -- 10% --
Contradict previous statement -- -- 8% --
Delays in court proceedings -- 11% 3% --
Literacy or language barriers 30% 10% -- 16%
Victim disinterest or fear or reluctance on part of victim 5% 6% -- 13%
Time constraints 16% 7% -- 21%
Detracts from sentencing guidelines -- -- 14% --
Victims are coached -- -- 5% --
Are given too much weight in sentencing -- -- 3% --
Perception that is not considered 8% -- -- 12%
Crown Attorney or judicial reluctance 10% -- -- 8%
Lack of awareness by criminal justice professionals -- -- -- 4%
Other 12% 13% 13% 6%
No response -- 4% 5% 9%